Monday, December 10, 2007

I trust in God, it’s as simple as that

This post has been a long time coming. I haven’t spoken about God, the Catholic Church or my faith much on this blog (partly because I know that many readers don’t share that faith, partly because it is so private, and partly because I am still figuring it all out), but in light of recent events and some things I’ve read recently, I guess now is the time. So. I am Catholic. This is part of the reason it took me so long to come to terms with being gay, I don’t deny it.

But I’m getting ahead of myself here. Let’s start at the beginning. Sister and I were never dragged to church kicking and screaming as children like our parents were. We found God on our own. Despite not going to church as a child, I always considered myself Catholic, I just didn’t know what it entailed exactly.

Fast forward to 1999, the year I became ill, a year filled with uncertainty, depression and anxiety over my identity and place in the world. I was fifteen. I went to a lunch-time Christian group, ostensibly non-denominational but in practice fiercely Pentecostal (the friend I mentioned in the post “Insidious” also attended the group). One lunch time we were discussing differences between the denominations of Christianity and it turned into an open slather forum on what was wrong with Catholicism. As I didn’t know much about the church, I struggled to refute their accusations of heresy. My self-esteem and sense of self shattered, I decided to go to mass that weekend. At the mass there was an announcement about a weekend for youth that was being held at the parish in a month’s time. I put my name down. I went. I had a great time.

It was at this weekend that I “found God”. It wasn’t as glittery as Damascus, but it was sufficiently euphoric nonetheless. It was also at this weekend that I caught the flu, which ultimately lead to my ME/CFS.

Over the next two years, I went to mass and to the youth group and I learned about God, Jesus, Mary, John-Paul II and the whole crew. I was confirmed at 16 in 2000. It was around this time that the question of sexuality reared its ugly head. I knew I liked boys, I didn’t want to, but I did nonetheless. God knew I did, despite my best efforts to hide it from everyone, even Him. We were given a copy of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which says this on the matter:

“Homosexuality refers to relations between men or between women who experience an exclusive or predominant sexual attraction toward persons of the same sex. It has taken a great variety of forms through the centuries and in different cultures. Its psychological genesis remains largely unexplained. Basing itself on Sacred Scripture, which presents homosexual acts as acts of grave depravity, tradition has always declared that "homosexual acts are intrinsically disordered." They are contrary to the natural law. They close the sexual act to the gift of life. They do not proceed from a genuine affective and sexual complementarity. Under no circumstances can they be approved.” (CCC 2357)
At this point, I was really confused.

After the watershed, I stopped going to mass. I felt unwanted and unvalued. Four years later I finally admitted I was gay. But I still didn’t know where this fit in with my faith in God and religion, so I did my best to ignore it. It didn’t work. I finally worked out that they are two separate issues: faith is private, religion is public. Two years later I’m still working it out.

So where does that leave me? I believe in the God of love, yet my religion continues its campaign of hate against my gay, lesbian, bi, transgender and intersex brothers and sisters. I read a recent interview with Anglican Archbishop Desmond Tutu:
He said the Anglican Church had seemed “extraordinarily homophobic” in its handling of the issue, and that he had felt “saddened” and “ashamed” of his church at the time.
Asked if he still felt ashamed, he said: “If we are going to not welcome or invite people because of sexual orientation, yes.”
“If God, as they say, is homophobic, I wouldn’t worship that God.”
The Catholic Church is much the same, maybe even more so. I agree with what Archbishop Tutu says. I do not worship a homophobic God.

I still don’t know how it all fits together, to be honest, but that is what faith is: belief despite doubt or trouble. At the moment I’m waiting to be put in touch with a friend of Kate’s who is a gay pastor; I’m hoping he can help me connect the seemingly unending string of contradictory connect-the-dots. But, the way I see it, we mere mortals can’t blame God because there are other homophobic mortals working for him, purporting to speak for him. I often think “it must be nice to be so assured” when I hear Sister and the “unknowing homophobes” spout their rubbish and hate. But the point is I believe in God’s love more than I reject the church’s hate.

I trust in God, it’s as simple as that.

7 comments ... click here to comment:

Superdrewby said...

You know my feelings on the catholic church and on my faith.

You can believe in a higher being and be gay that is a basic belief of mine.

However the catholic church has twisted and used the issue as a divisive and control tactic and it's the catholic church that I cannot believe in...

Campbell said...

Well done for being open about this before you have it 'all figured out' Dan. Life is about the figuring out rather than the figured out.

TheDreamer said...

I saw the Tutu article and thought 'finally, someone religious finally gets it'. I think your distinction is accurate and defensible - it's not belief in God per se that is the problem - it's the power structures, control and biblical literalism that the Church (notably the Catholic Church) wraps around us to make us feel guilty and subservient to them.

That said, ever wondered if there was more than a random connection between you 'finding God' and you getting ill? I would have thought that being gay and being religious was just the kind of stress that could presage such an illness. Perhaps you could do with losing God in order to find yourself fully...

tundratomo said...

as always, dan, still reading,,,,,, this one struck home. i went thru hell being raised catholic over the ''masturbation'' issue. It finally resulted in my leaving the church and almost total lack of any faith, except to hope that we should only answer to him and not to a very unworthy church. i wish you well as always, great blog.

Dan said...

Thanks for the comments guys :)

Just a few thoughts on what The Dreamer has said... I'm not writing this to attack or nit-pick, just to clarify a few things.

Yes, I've thought about the correlation between becoming ill and "finding God" (which, I should add, is a bit of a hyperbole... it was more a rekindling of faith than a full-on conversion experience) on many a sleepless night. Constantly.

But I don't think that my absense at that particular weekend would have prevented my illness. I was already unwell at that point, I just hadn't been tipped over the edge; now, eight years later, I am so far gone that there is no way that avoiding a simple case of the flu would have avoided this hell.

Also, at the time of that weekend retreat, I wasn't thinking too much on being gay. That came after hearing what people in the church were saying about it.

Incidently, I find the Catholic position on "being gay" to be a little more balanced and reasonable than that of many protestant groups. Classic Catholicism (the CCC) teaches that one must be celebate if one is attracted to the same sex. It is the fundamentalist, evangelical, ultra-conservative protestant groups, as a general rule, that advocate conversion therapy and ex-gay ministries. So whereas the Catholic church says you should stay celebate, these other groups say that you should change yourself and become straight, which brings with it a whole host of psychological issues. At least the Catholic church respects that you cannot change. But that said, they all unite in their quest to block human rights and legal equality issues, which obviously I reject.

But yes, you're right, the stress at that point in my life definitely contributed to my declining health and
depression.

As for loosing God, I tried my hardest, as a teenager, but I can't. It's like asking me to believe there is no sun.

I guess ultimately faith, in anything, can be a blessing and a curse. Just in varying degrees for some people.

D

thedreamer said...

Fair enough. I concede how hard it might be to 'lose' God. It wasn't my intention to doubt your faith, or encourage you to question it - you are clearly doing that yourself, and it is right of you to point out that in amongst the strident voices of 'ex-gay' movements are many more moderate and nuanced positions.

Even so, I just can't imagine imposing a life of forced celibacy upon myself. I did that for over a year once, and it nearly drove me mad. It wasn't the lack of the act of sex per so, it was the absence of touch. I guess I just need some 'impure' actions to go with my 'impure' thoughts. It's just that I don't think they are 'impure'...

Dan said...

It's ok Dreamer, I knew what your intention was to provide food for thought, not to push me towards abandoning anything. No harm, no foul.

But for the record, I don't subscribe to the Catholic party line on this issue of celebacy. I don't see why people should be celebate because of who they are attracted to. There are other, more important and worthy, reasons for celebacy. Being a fag ain't one of em. Impurity isn't the issue.

D :)