I was going to write this entry in third person, like the previous one, but I don't have the energy or the will to do it; it's surprisingly exhausting writing it up like some detached story, rather than just saying how I feel.
We were in the car -- Dad, Sister and I -- driving home after picking Sister up from the train station. I asked her about her day. Big mistake. She told me that in her ethics class the debate topic was "Should we allow gay marriage?". The class has been doing a series of ethics debates, designed to get students to think and articulate their views coupled with learning the ethics of the various situations. Sister did hers on euthanasia.
She was telling us about the various arguments brought up in class: "they should be allowed to have the same rights as heterosexual couples", "but marriage is a sacramental covenant between a man and a woman", "they should do this", "they shouldn't do that", they, they, they. It's us against them in her mind.
Whoever said "sticks and stones will break my bones but words will never hurt me" obviously wasn't gay and didn't live with my sister; they were full of shit.
But unlike every other time the topic has come up, this time I didn't, couldn't, remain silent. I just quietly said "I disagree". She asked me to elaborate. I said "I hate the argument that 'allowing gay marriage will destroy the fabric of society'. If marriage is the building block of society the its just another marriage. Who cares if it's two men or two women or one of each?"
She said "I can't believe you think that way!" My father, who up until this point was silent just quietly said "yes it will". That gutted me.
She talked about marriage being a sacramental union. I said that I don't believe the Catholic Church -- or any church or religion for that matter -- holds the patent on marriage. It existed before they did.
At this point we arrived home and I walked inside, she followed me around telling me that two men or two woman can't have real love, because real love can only exist between a man and a woman; that sex between two men or two women isn't real sex, real sex is a man and a woman; that a marriage can't be a marriage without consummation and consummation means a man a woman sharing their love and their souls; that when a man and a woman fuck they face each other, signifying their love and sharing, whereas when two men fuck they don't (she hasn't seen much gay porn obviously lol); that gay marriage is a mockery of real marriage and "why should they force themselves into a heterosexual mould when they don't fit?"; that she can't believe I disagree.
I wonder if this will get her thinking about my motives for feeling this way. I suspect Dad's mind is going to be turning over and he'll figure it out.
The die is cast. I have a feeling that they will find out I'm gay very soon.
We're reaching a point of no return here. That scares me.
Thursday, October 12, 2006
The die is cast
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)














8 comments ... click here to comment:
awww you need some hugs!
Once you get to apoint where you start standing up for gay rights in front of your family you know you are becoming more confidant in being gay around them.... I think you are right when you say they will know son enough. Im very proud of you for standing up to your sister though!
Oh and I think she will fail her paper if the idea is to think outside the square... her square is very small.
I'm proud of you too. There is no shame in being gay, don't let anyone try to tell you otherwise.
And, as a gay guy, you're not alone. Check out:
http://joshandjosh.typepad.com/
It's great!! I think every gay guy should leave a message on their coming out day post!
Yes it would be nice for you to tell your family that you are gay. And so you should, why should you have to keep it a huge secret burdening on your mind?
However, I urge careful consideration and make sure that YOU are ready for the possible rejection of your family members who are clearly set in their ways. They may change their mind, but if they're deeply religious in the belief that homosexuality is a sin and that one can't possibly have relationship with somebody else of the same sex, then telling them could be quite detrimental.
So, make sure that you are ready for it because you won't be able to jump back into the closet if they don't take it very well... Let us know how it goes regardless.
hugs hugs hugs.
good on you dude.
oh! look at moye look at moyeeeeee!
I've got one word to say to you.
amidevie!!
Ouch, hadn't expected your dad to make that move, if anything I thought he'd be the one that was most OK with it.
Does she know the difference between Chrisian marriage and other sorts of marriage? Its an incredibly narrow scope and comparitively modern institution she's basing her views on there.
Not much room to move when you are so positive you are right and the rest of the world is wrong. Its a shame, because she's an intelligent little thing. :(
Buck up, you know we are all here for you if things go pear shaped :)
Way to go Dan. You are much braver than I am. I know those arguments well. They are the same ones that I've heard and have even used in the past. Back in the days when I thought maybe if I defended the church's position God would make be straight. I can't help but think that eventually people will realize that all the ideas they hold are really just misconceptions.
Stay strong man.
I used to defend it -- believe it -- too, for the same reasons as Drew: the mistaken belief it would make me straight.
It didn't, doesn't, work.
with you mate. stand tall. you've got nothing to be ashamed of. nobody has the right to make any of us feel like we're not equal and not deserving of the same rights as everyone else. who really knows if there's a God or not, but if there is, I can't imagine he/she/it could care one bit where we stick our dicks or who we choose to spend our lives with.
Post a Comment